[Taiwan Supreme Court Case] Good Faith as a Defense in Patent Litigation
[ November 02, 2026 ] >Back| The principle of good faith, set forth in Article 148, Paragraph 2 of Taiwan's Civil Code, is often described as the Civil Code's paramount provision. Because the concept of good faith is relatively indeterminate, however, it is rarely invoked as a defense in patent litigation. In Supreme Court Civil Judgment 2025 Tai-Shang-Zi No. 275 (最高法院114年度台上字第275號民事判決), the Supreme Court relied on this uncommon defense to set aside the lower court's judgment and remand the case to the court of second instance. The reasoning behind that decision warrants attention. Background VIAVI Solutions Inc. ("VIAVI"), a U.S. company, owns the patent titled "Filter and Sensor System" (the "Patent-in-Suit"). VIAVI brought multiple patent infringement actions against Taiwan-based Platinum Optics Technology Inc. ("Platinum") in Taiwan and China. The parties subsequently signed a settlement agreement on April 29, 2020, under which VIAVI agreed not to bring any further infringement actions in any country against products manufactured and sold by Platinum before the settlement agreement took effect, based on the Patent-in-Suit or any substantially identical patent. Nevertheless, on August 7, 2020, VIAVI filed a patent infringement action against Platinum in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. VIAVI alleged that Platinum had continued to manufacture and sell products that infringed the Patent-in-Suit after the settlement agreement was executed. The Courts' Analysis At the second-instance stage, the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court initially held that VIAVI had not breached the settlement agreement. The reasoning was straightforward: because VIAVI had expressly limited the allegations in its U.S. complaint to conduct occurring after May 1, 2020, the complaint did not, on its face, contravene the settlement agreement. However, the Supreme Court took a different view, reasoning as follows: The parties had previously been involved in patent infringement litigation and entered into the agreement at issue on April 29, 2020. Under the agreement, VIAVI was prohibited from bringing patent infringement actions in any country against any products manufactured and sold by Platinum before the agreement took effect, based on the Patent-in-Suit. Article 1 of the agreement further provided that VIAVI would withdraw, within three business days after the agreement became effective, the patent infringement actions it had brought against Platinum in Taiwan and China. These provisions appear to indicate that the parties’ original intent in the agreement was to end the existing patent disputes and to prevent unnecessary future litigation arising from such disputes.
Yet just over three months after the agreement was concluded, VIAVI filed the U.S. patent infringement action against Platinum on August 7 of the same year. VIAVI submitted only the filter-product materials it had previously submitted in the China litigation, without presenting any other relevant new evidence. If VIAVI arbitrarily brought the U.S. infringement action knowing that it had no new evidence of any further infringement of the Patent-in-Suit by Platinum, thereby causing Platinum to incur unnecessary costs and effort in its defense, and undermining Platinum's reasonable reliance on, and expectation of, VIAVI's faithful performance of the agreement, the question of whether such conduct is consistent with the principle of good faith and does not constitute a breach of contract warrants further consideration. Key Takeaway The Supreme Court emphasized that the purpose of the settlement agreement was to end the existing disputes and prevent unnecessary future litigation. If a party initiates litigation arbitrarily without new evidence, the mere act of filing the action may force the opposing party to incur substantial legal fees to defend itself and undermine the opposing party's reasonable expectations under the settlement agreement. In such circumstances, the filing of the action may violate the principle of good faith and constitute a breach of contract. The above views are the author's personal views and do not represent the position of the firm. Attorney Yi-Ta Tsai 2026/11/02 Should you have any further questions regarding this article, please feel free to contact us via email (jawhwa@jaw-hwa.com.tw). |