Patent Warning Letters in Taiwan: Four Legal Risks to Avoid from the Tetong v. Apple Case
[ November 04, 2026 ] >Back| Patent infringement warning letters are commonly used to enforce patent rights. However, improperly issued warning letters may expose patent owners to liability under Taiwan's Fair Trade Act and Civil Code, potentially resulting in substantial damages and personal liability for company directors. The Intellectual Property and Commercial Court's Civil Judgment No. 64 of 2024 (113年度民專訴字第64號), involving Tetong Technology (特通科技) and Apple Asia LLC, illustrates these risks. The court ordered Tetong and two of its responsible persons to pay NT$600,000 (approximately US$19,000) in damages to Apple Asia LLC, jointly and severally. I. Background of the Case Tetong Technology (“Tetong”) held several invention and utility model patents relating to USB Type-C technology. Suspecting infringement, Tetong sent a patent warning letter directly to Apple Asia LLC (“Apple Asia”), a Taiwan distributor, demanding a license, and subsequently initiated infringement proceedings.
However, the same patents had previously been found invalid in separate litigation against Micro-Star International (MSI). Despite knowing of these validity issues, Tetong continued asserting its patents against other businesses. Apple Asia subsequently filed a counterclaim, alleging that Tetong's warning letters and enforcement actions constituted unfair competition and tortious conduct. The court ultimately ruled against Tetong, prohibiting it from issuing further warning letters concerning the patents to Apple Asia or its trading counterparties and awarding NT$600,000 in damages. II. Four Key Legal Risks 1. Utility Model Patents Require Official Technical Evaluation Reports
Unlike invention patents, utility model patents in Taiwan undergo only formality examination, without substantive examination. Their validity may therefore be uncertain.
Article 116 of the Patent Act and the Fair Trade Commission's principles governing infringement warning letters establish requirements for asserting utility model patent rights. In this case, Tetong failed to provide the required technical evaluation report issued by TIPO and instead attempted to present a privately prepared infringement analysis as an official technical evaluation report. The court emphasized that a private infringement analysis cannot substitute for an official technical evaluation report and found Tetong's conduct deceptive and obviously unfair. 2. Sending Warning Letters to Distributors Without Notifying Manufacturers Under Points 3 and 4 of the Fair Trade Commission's principles governing infringement warning letters, businesses must notify the relevant manufacturer, importer, or agent in advance or simultaneously when issuing warning letters to distributors or retailers.
This requirement is intended to prevent patent owners from improperly disrupting market competition by targeting downstream businesses that may lack the technical expertise to assess infringement allegations. Tetong sent its warning letter directly to Apple Asia without notifying Apple Inc. in the United States. The court found that this conduct affected trading order and violated Article 25 of the Fair Trade Act. 3. Asserting Patents Despite Known Validity Defects Although a civil court's determination of patent validity generally applies only to the particular case, continuing to assert patents despite known serious validity defects may constitute an abuse of rights.
In this case, despite the earlier MSI ruling, Tetong continued to pursue infringement actions against more than 30 businesses. The court found that Tetong knowingly concealed significant validity defects while continuing its enforcement activities, constituting tortious conduct under Article 184 of the Civil Code and Article 30 of the Fair Trade Act. 4. Liability for Defense Expenses and Company Responsible Persons Improper patent warning letters may result in liability for reasonable expenses incurred by recipients in defending their interests.
In this case, Apple Asia sought compensation for legal assessment fees and patent invalidation expenses incurred in response to Tetong's conduct. The court distinguished these expenses from attorney fees incurred in the infringement proceedings, which are addressed separately as litigation costs under Article 15 of the Intellectual Property Case Adjudication Act. The court ultimately assessed the damages at NT$600,000 at its discretion under Article 222, paragraph 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Importantly, the court also imposed joint and several liability on Tetong's registered responsible person and de facto responsible person under the Company Act. This demonstrates that improper patent enforcement may expose not only the company itself but also individuals responsible for directing or authorizing such actions to personal liability. III. Practical Implications The Tetong v. Apple case highlights the importance of exercising patent rights carefully and in compliance with Taiwan's legal requirements.
Before issuing patent infringement warning letters, businesses should verify the validity of their patents, obtain the required technical evaluation reports where applicable, conduct appropriate infringement assessments, and comply with the relevant notification procedures. Companies should also maintain internal records of their enforcement decisions to demonstrate that their responsible persons have exercised appropriate care. Proper preparation can help patent owners protect their rights while minimizing the risk of counterclaims, damages, and personal liability. The above views are the author's personal views and do not represent the position of the firm. Attorney Yi-Ta Tsai 2026/11/04 Should you have any further questions regarding this article, please feel free to contact us via email (jawhwa@jaw-hwa.com.tw). |